I've used Sterling 11mm Superstatic for caving. It works fine!
I cannot speak in any authoritative way to sheath durability, but it is a little stretchier than PMI Max-Wear or PMI EZ-Bend, and that can increase abrasion because more stretch translates to bigger sawing motions over edges. Avoid or pad any aggressive edges (and flat-out avoid any sharp ones, to the point of thinking about what's going to happen to your rope if a single non-redundant component of your anchor system, like a bolt, fails). You know, like you would do anyway.
I've seen Sterling 11mm Superstatic (rigged by climbers as rappel lines) abrade on edges...it seems to abrade faster than 11mm PMI ropes, but I'm not sure the sheath thickness or construction actually has to do with that. The Sterling ropes have a higher number of fiber bundles in their sheaths, i.e. their sheaths are a finer weave. Some people say that this increases abrasion-resistance, though it has never been explained to me why that would be so.
I don't have access to samples of each to go back and compare, but the Sterling 11mm Superstatic always seemed
less supple to me than PMI 11mm EZ-Bend.
Initial testing on Sterling ropes suggests that WNS decontamination with the properly concentrated Lysol ICS solution (
not bleach!) is safe. The production of those results is an indication that Sterling has done more to assist in that research, thus far, than any other company. Those early results and the work that went into them speaks well for Sterling. PMI has a long history of being caver-friendly, and remains the most respected and most use manufacturer of caving ropes in the US. Blue Water also produces excellent ropes and has a good history of concern for caver needs--it was the original caving rope company. This history was established well before the debut of WNS. It is nice to see that Sterling is interested in the needs of cavers as well.
(Sterling also sponsored the vertical training session at the
Spring 2010 NRO.)
Overall, my personal favorite 11mm caving rope is PMI 11mm EZ-Bend.