I, for the most part, have tried to get away from collecting. Every time you move, you've got really heavy things to tote. And then there's the issue of displaying them. So I have some of my very best, and that's all. Plus my latest, prized nummulatites, but I'm trying to be on my FA plan (fossils anonymous).
But I'm here for ya, BA. I know that bein' a fossil collector is *not* the same thing as being a cave vandal. With a few exceptions, caves are lousy places to collect fossils.
Maybe we can have a one-per-thread "I'M NOT GOING TO COLLECT IN CAVES" statement, or maybe BA can put that statement in his signature line or something so that it's clear to everyone that the wrong message is not going out publically that a caver can simultaneously have a second hobby that includes collecting fossils from roadcuts and quarries and stuff.
Oh, BTW, one of the Germans on my trip to India worked with a museum and spent almost every weekend collecting Jurassic ammonites in a quarry back home. They moved the Oxforidan/Kimmerigian boundary by a good 5 meters based on his collecting. Rah, yeah, ammateur paleontologists!!!!