Moderator: Moderators
the quote was pretty good but if I wrote it here someone might scream copyright.
wendy wrote:When I first saw that ad I was a little dissappointed, I was flipping thru the magazine, and saw the photo of the cave and thought it was a cool article on caves
Cheryl Jones wrote:the quote was pretty good but if I wrote it here someone might scream copyright.
Not if you credit the source and don't claim it as your own.
Cindy Heazlit wrote:This statement on copyright isn't true. People seem to think that they can use text, credit the source, and be OK. Nope - it is still copyright violation. You are, however, allowed to quote the text for the purpose of commentary, which is what is happening on this thread. So bremen66 is OK on that context.
NZcaver wrote:wendy wrote:When I first saw that ad I was a little dissappointed, I was flipping thru the magazine, and saw the photo of the cave and thought it was a cool article on caves
Why were you "initially disappointed"? I'm just curious - I've heard other cavers say they've been disappointed/upset by products being advertised in conjunction with caves/caving. I can't say that kind of thing has ever bothered me, but perhaps other cavers have a different take on this..?
wendy wrote:and jump into some big hole and do a balls to the wall decent,
Cindy Heazlit wrote:Cheryl Jones wrote:the quote was pretty good but if I wrote it here someone might scream copyright.
Not if you credit the source and don't claim it as your own.
This statement on copyright isn't true. People seem to think that they can use text, credit the source, and be OK. Nope - it is still copyright violation. You are, however, allowed to quote the text for the purpose of commentary, which is what is happening on this thread. So bremen66 is OK on that context.
wendy wrote:not disappointed that it was an ad with a cave in it, but sad that it wasn't the front page of an article on caving.
The only cave related commercial I didn't like, was the car one where they rig the rope to the SUV and jump into some big hole and do a balls to the wall decent, with no rope pad or doing things the safe way. that I thnk gives a bad message, but that would have been a bad message on safety even if the car ad didn't have a cave in it
NZcaver wrote:Cindy Heazlit wrote:Cheryl Jones wrote:the quote was pretty good but if I wrote it here someone might scream copyright.
Not if you credit the source and don't claim it as your own.
This statement on copyright isn't true. People seem to think that they can use text, credit the source, and be OK. Nope - it is still copyright violation. You are, however, allowed to quote the text for the purpose of commentary, which is what is happening on this thread. So bremen66 is OK on that context.
Sorry to swerve off topic, but according to the US Copyright Office the only criminal infringements of copyright occur when somebody infringes "willfully for purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain", or "by the reproduction or distribution...of copyright works which have a total retail value of more than $1,000."
Return to Caving General Discussion and Questions Forum
Users browsing this forum: No registered users